Epidemiological Analysis of Mothers
under Gone Caesarean Section at Medical College Hospital
Dhruv (Thakur) Shashi Kala1,
Bansal A.2, Dhruv V.K.3, Kar, P.K.4, Rathi
H.B.5 and Shrivastava, P.K.5
Dept. of Pathology1, OBG2, Anaesthesia3,
Dean4 and Community Medicine5,
Govt. Medical College, Jagdalpur, (Bastar) - 494001, India.
ABSTRACT:
Back ground: The distress, pain and struggle
through a difficult labour is neither well tolerated by patients nor
appreciated by Obstetrician. So use of Caesarean Section to terminate painful
and difficult labour has increased the incidence tremendously. Objective: the objective was to study
the determinants of Caesarian Section among mothers under gone the procedure. Material and Methods: The mothers under
gone Caesarean Section in a medical college hospital. Study variables included
mother’s age, weight, Gravida, Gestational age, Basal pulse rate , Mean
arterial pressure in mm. Hg., prity, history of previous Caesarean Section in
earlier delivery. Statistical Analysis:
The results were expressed in terms of mean ± SEM and proportion as
and when required. Observations: Highest
percentage of caesarean section has the previous history of the procedure in
earlier delivery which was in accordance of the adage “once a caesarean always
a caesarean”. Vertex was the commonest presentation (81.11 %).Conclusion: The mothers who are at risk
for Caesarean should be identified and high quality ante natal care should be
given in order to minimize the complications of the procedure. As an
unnecessary surgery is jeopardizing women’s health, hence before recommending
the procedure, all alternative method must be explored.
KEYWORDS: Caesarean, Presentation, Mean.
INTRODUCTION:
Perhaps the most notable change in present
day obstetric practices is the increase in acceptable indications for
performing Caesarean Section (C.S.). The free availability of blood
transfusions, the introduction of newer antibiotics, improvement in the
administration of anesthesia etc have contributed towards making C.S. a safe
operation even when it is performed in cases of delayed, obstructed labour.
“The relative safety of the operation leads people to think it’s as safe as
vaginal birth,” said Dr. A. Metin Gulmezoglu, who co-authored the Asia report.
“That’s unlikely to be the case.” Few studies have been conducted in India so
far to assess the determinants of C. S. Studies of such nature will be useful
tool to make appropriate interventional measures. In this context and in 1957 a
study group of World Health Organization has expressed the view that in order
to get a comprehensive picture of disease (health problem) more and more
studies have to be carried out, Garg Narendra K.(1). This prompted the authors
to undertake this study to elucidate some of the major risk factors for C.S.
MATERIAL AND METHODS:
Eighty five pregnant women
undergone Caesarean Section in G. M. Hospital and S. S. Medical College, Rewa
were included in the study.
All the patients age, weight
pulse rate, blood pressure, respiratory rate were recorded. Mother’s obstetrics
history (13) was also recorded in a pre drawn proforma. The observations thus
collected were tabulated and analyzed.
OBSERVATIONS:
On analysis of the collected
data of eighty five mothers under gone C. S., it has been revealed that the
various parameters recorded from mothers undergone caesarean section in two
groups under study (Study and Control). The study group’s mean age was 32.74
years in comparison to the control group mean age 26.8 years with the age being
comparable in study to control groups (Table – I) The mean weight was 54.7 Kgs.
in study group in comparison to their counterparts 52.12 Kgs. in control group.
The table further revealed that the mean gestation age was comparable in both
the group and was 39.3 weeks to 39.6 weeks. As far as the mean gravida was
concerned in these two groups (study and control) these were 2.95 to 2.11.in
control and study group respectively. The table also shows that the mean pulse
rate was comparable in study to control group being 95.88 and 92.12 per
minutes. The mean arterial pressure was recorded in study and control group was
101.9and 94.38 mm of Hg respectively.
Table – I: Average preoperative
data of mothers undergoing caesarean section
|
S.
No. |
Data |
Study
Group |
Control
Group |
|
1 |
Age
in year |
32.74
± 2.46 |
26.8
± 2.46 |
|
2 |
Weight
in Kg. |
54.7
± 2.97 |
52.12
± 3.60 |
|
3 |
Gravidity |
2.11
± 1.25 |
2.95
± 1.16 |
|
4 |
Gestational
age |
39.3
± 1.59 |
3936
± 1.38 |
|
5 |
Basal
Pulse rate per minute |
95.38
± 14.15 |
92.12
± 5.30 |
|
6 |
Mean
arterial Pressure in mm Hg. |
101.19
± 10.19 |
94.38
± 5.53 |
Table – II: Incidence of various
indications in all the patients
|
S.
No. |
Indication |
Study
Group |
Control
Group |
|
1 |
Previous
section |
33% |
36% |
|
2 |
Breech |
13% |
4% |
|
3 |
C.P.D. |
13% |
24% |
|
4 |
Non
Progressive |
11% |
8% |
|
5 |
Prolapse |
6% |
4% |
|
6 |
Placenta
previa |
5% |
12% |
|
7 |
Others |
16% |
12% |
[Table – II] The percentage of
various indications for caesarean section in the study group and control group,
many cases also had multiple indications. The highest percentage of cases had,
previous section 33% as the indication for the caesarean section followed by
Cephalo Pelvic Disproportion (C.P.D.) 13%, Breech, 13% Non progressive 11 % and
Prolapsed genital cord and hand 6%, placenta previa 5% and cervical dystocia
etc. 16% in study group while I n control group, previous section 36%, Breech
4%, C.P.D. 24%, Non progressive 8%, prolapse 4%, placenta previa 12% and other
12% .The other indications like cervical dystocia, Mitral stenosis, pulmonary
hypertension, elderly primi, bad obstetric history and contracted pelvic were
in the both group. It was further noted that 33% and 16 % of the cases were
premigravida in both study control group respectively.
[Table – III] The occurrence of
various presentations in the both group, Vertex was the most common
presentation, being 75% of study group, 96% of the control group; Breech
presentation represented 13% and 4% respectively in both the groups. Table
further revealed that in study group 08 percent mothers who have undergone C.S.
were because of Transverse Lie in comparision to none in their counter parts
control group. Similarily in study group 02 % each mothers under gone C.S.
because they have been diagnosed, Brow and Footling presentation again none in
control group.
Table – III: Percentage
incidence of various presentation in both groups
|
S.
No. |
Presentation |
Study
Group |
Control
Group |
|
1 |
Vertex |
75% |
96% |
|
2 |
Breech |
13% |
4% |
|
3 |
Transverse
lie |
8% |
- |
|
4 |
Brow |
2% |
- |
|
5 |
Footing |
2% |
- |
DISCUSSIONS:
C. P. D. were the largest group
(50 %) it includes grossly contracted pelvis, pelvis of normal shaoe in which
some of the diameters are small, a pelvis of normal shape but size of the fetus
was disproportionaly large and occipitoposterior position. There can be no
disagreement about elective C. S. in cases of major degrees of disproportion
are subjected to C. S. only after a proper trial of labour has been
un-successful. All cases of persistent brow presentation at or above mid pelvic
plane are best delivered by C.S. In only few cases of breech presentation C.S.
is indicated. In 1960-61 in N.W.M. hospital less than 1 percent cases were
delivered by C. S., the adage “once a C. S. always a C. S.”(11), this doctrine
was established by Craigin in 1916. The incidence of C. S. is steadily rising.
During the last decade there has been two to three fold rise in the incidence
from the initial rate of about 10 % (12).The findings of the present study were
more or less in accordance of the various studies carried out across the Globe
by various authors.
A U. S. studies have revealed
that babies born by C.S. have greater chance for respiratory problems. The Asia
survey found that the procedure benefits babies during breech presentation.
Reasons for elective C-sections vary globally, but increasing rates in many
developing countries coincide with a rise in patients’ wealth and improved
medical facilities (2). The vertex was the commonest presentation (81.11 %)
which is in conformity with the established incidence of vertex presentation in
pregnancy.
In Asia, some women opt for the
surgery to choose their delivery day after consulting fortune tellers for
“lucky” birthdays or times. Others fear painful natural births or worry their
vaginas may be stretched or damaged by a normal delivery. Some women also
prefer the operation because they mistakenly believe it is less risky.
“I think it’s safer for the
mother and child to have C-sections and the relatives feel more secure because
it’s very simple and very common now,”said a Vietnamese woman, Trang Thanh Van,
25, just days away from giving birth to her first child. “People worry that
using tools to pull the baby out (in a vaginal birth) may affect their brains.”
China’s 46 percent C-section
rate was followed by Vietnam and Thailand with 36 percent and 34 percent,
respectively. The lowest rates were in Cambodia, with 15 percent and India,
with 18 percent.
The study did not discuss
specific reasons for the high number of C-sections, but it noted that more than
60 percent of the hospitals studied were motivated by financial incentives to
perform surgeries (2).
As the capital’s largest
maternity hospital (National Hospital of Gynaecology and Obstetrics in Hanoi,
Vietnam), about 40 percent of the 20,000 babies delivered there annually are by
C. S., according to Dr. Le Anh Tuan, the hospital’s vice director, who did not
participate in the study. It receives the most complicated cases, with many
women undergoing emergency surgery, but he said another reason is women with
small frames whose babies are simply too large for them to deliver naturally.
Dr. Le said “the babies are
bigger even than the Western countries,” he further added “Vietman was a
country where we did not have enough food to eat; now we have a surplus of
food. The mothers believe that if they eat a lot, their babies will be
healthy”.
In Latin America .C.S. rates in
all eight countries surveyed earlier by World Health Organization (W.H.O.) were
thirty percent or even higher –similar to the U.S. rate. In Paraguay and
Ecuador, 42 and 40 % of deliveries respectively were by C. S. It is further
noted that some expectant mothers scheduled elective surgeries to avoid giving
birth during holidays or even so they could attend parties ,according to Dr. Archana
Shah, W. H. O. in Geneva, who worked on that report and cautioned that data in
both studies represent a sample that may not reflect overall national rates.
Hanoi, Vietnam – nearly half of
all birth in China are delivered by C.S., the world’s highest rate, according
to a survey of W.H.O. –a shift towards modernization that is not necessarily a
good thing. The U.N.health agency warned that the woom in unnecessary surgeries
is jeopardizing women’s health (lancet) The report further revealed that unwanted
C. S. are costlier than natural birth and raise the risk of complications for
the mother. Report further added that C. S. have reached “Epidemic proportion
“in many countries worldwide (2) Survey was conducted in nine Asian nations.
The report revealed that the most dramatic findings in China where 46 % of
births reviewed were C.S. - a quarter of them not medically necessary. In
Beijing capital of China, according to Dr. He Yuanhua, who did not participate
in the study, at Capital Antai Obsetrics and Gynaecology Hospital “So many
expectant mothers asked for C.S., but we always suggest that they have a
natural birth.” “It’s bad to have so many C.S. because natural birth is ideal
one” In 2007 – 08, W. H. O. reviewed 110,000 births across Asia and found that
twenty seven percent were carried out under knife, partially motivated by
hospitals eager to make money (2). From above observations and discussions the
authors reached to the conclusion that in the community there are some myths eg
operation is less risky, because of the fear of the distress, pain and struggle
during labour, because in rise in patients wealth ,some of the husbands think
that after vaginal delivery sex pleasure may lessen ,because of lucky
birthday’s or times, etc. some hospitals were motivated for financial gain and
in India ,the medical reimbursement policy is also responsible up to some
extent, but all these are jeopardizing women’s health, hence efforts must be
made to bring awareness in the community because natural birth is the ideal way.
Any C.S. is performed only in the interest of the mother and child – and that
too after a careful evaluation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
The authors express their cordial thanks to
Mr. Anand Singh Kanwar,
Lab-Technician, Deptt. of Community Medicine, Govt. Medical College, Jagdalpur
(C.G.) for his neat and excellent typing.
REFERENCES:
1.
Garg Narendra K. Evaluation of the impact of emesis and emesis
plus purgation therapy; Research J. Pharmacology and Pharmacodynamics: 2 (2)
March – April 2010; 201-202.
2.
C - Section rates around globe at ‘epidemic’ levels – Health –
Pregnancy – msnbc.com; page no. 3 & 5.
3.
Bansal A.K. and Chandorkar R.K. (1993) knowledge, Belief and
Practice: A study of Tribal mothers about feeding of infants; Tribal Health
Bulletine (ICMR); Vol. – 2, No. – 3 & 4: 1-2.
4.
Bansal A.K. and Chandorkar R.K. (1993) effectiveness of ICDS in
child care in Rural and Tribal areas of Chhattisgarh (M.P.) J. Ravi Shankar
uni; Vol. – 6, No.-B (Science) 61-65.
5.
Bansal A.K. and Saxena V.B. (2000) impact of I.C.D.S. on Pregnancy
pattern of Tribal and Non Tribal women. J. Ravi Shankar uni; Vol. – 13, No.-B
(Science) 54-58.
6.
Bansal A.K. and Chandorkar R.K. (1993) utilization of Health Care
delivery by Tribal and Non Tribal women of an ICDS block (1993) J. Ravi Shankar
uni; Vol.-6, No.-B (Science) 57-60.
7.
Bansal A.K., Agarwal Ashok K. and Govila A.K. (1998-99) Status of
girl child amongst Tribal and Non Tribal in the unreached rural India; J. Ravi
Shankar uni; Vol. – 11-12, No.-B (Science) 31-36.
8.
Bansal A.K. and Agarwal A.K. (1994) impact of training the
knowledge of Tribal and Non Tribal Anganwade workers; J. Ravi Shankar uni; Vol.
– 7, No.-B (Science) 51-54.
9.
Bansal A.K. and Chandorkar R.K. (1997) Immunization status of
Tribal and Non Tribal Children of Raipur district, Madhya Pradesh; Tribal
Health Bulletin (ICMR) Vol. – 3, No.-2; 12-14.
10.
Bansal A.K. and Chandorkar R.K. Impact of I.C.D.S. on morbidity
due to Nutritional deficiency Diseases amongst Tribe and Non Tribe Children;
Research J Science and Tech.; 2009: 1(2); 82-84.
11.
Masani K.M.: A Text Book of Obstetrics (1964) Caesarean Section;
pp 705 – 718.
12.
Dutta ,D.C. : Text Book of Obstetrics ( 2004 ) 6th.Edition ; published
:New Central Book Agency (P) Ltd.,8/1,Chintamoni Das Lane .Calcutta 700 009
(INDIA) ; Caesarean Section : 588 -590.
13.
Masani K.M.: A Text Book of Gynaecology (1973) 7th
Edition Bombay Popular Prakashan, History taking; pp-69-73.
Received on 26.04.2011
Accepted on 15.05.2011
© A&V Publication all right
reserved
Research J. Pharmacology and
Pharmacodynamics. 3(3): May –June, 2011, 105-107